November 9, 2016

Don't Cover Me With Your Rhythms

As most of you have probably gathered from over the years, I are very opinionated about music. Almost everything that has do with music from a listener standpoint (as opposed to a musician/creator/performer of same) I have offered an opinion on.

Commercial radio? Sure thing. Country pop? Absolutely. Different genres? Goes without saying. Etc., etc., etc.? Ad nauseam.

One thing that really rubs me the wrong way is cover music. Not cover bands, for which they are a very important component to the enjoyment of music, but songs that are covered by other artists. For me, cover songs fall into three distinct categories:

1} songs covered per genre;
2} songs covered that put the original to shame;
3} songs covered for no other reason than to keep a bands name out there.

1} Songs covered per genre.

With some genres, cover songs are part and parcel of the repertoire. These genres include: Americana, Bluegrass, Alt-Country, Blues, Cajun/Zydeco and Jazz. For example, Bluegrass is notorious for doing cover songs of certain songs that actually make the song more enjoyable for the listener. Songs by The Grateful Dead come to mind. Can't stand the band but listening to a bluegrass version of Friend Of The Devil makes it palatable.

2} Songs covered that put the original to shame.

With some bands/artists, they can do a cover that not only puts the original to shame, but creates a top 40 hit in the process. Bob Dylan is notorious for having his stuff covered by bands/artists that create a top 20 hit in the process, like Jimi Hendrix with All Along The Watchtower and Manfred Mann with The Mighty Quinn. Or they may not crack the hot 100, but still create a version that kills, like The Hooters did with Don Henley's The Boys Of Summer. And of course, you can't forget Leadbelly's Black Betty, that was done by Ram Jam. And Johnny Cash w/Fiona Apple doing Bridge Over Troubled Water.

3} Songs covered for no other reason than to keep/get a bands name out there.

I'm sure you can come up with a few head scratchers in regards to certain songs being covered. The way I see it, if a band is long in the tooth or up and coming, one way to keep/get their name in the news (and corporations licking their shoes) is to do a mediocre cover song. Examples include U2 doing a crappy cover of Carl Carlton's Everlasting Love, Pearl Jam doing a weenie cover of J. Frank Wilson's The Last Kiss, Mr. Big's cover of Harry Chapin's Cat's In The Cradle, and The Atari Boy's atrocious cover of Boys Of Summer.

Feh. Double Feh. Triple Feh.

I actually wanted to go elsewhere with this post about cover songs, but ya know, the minute you decide to stop for the night, whatever Mr. Momentum you got going for yourself usually bites the big one. I mean, I mean, I mean, I'm just sitting here on the group W bench, minding my own business, when BAM!

 

I was struck down with case of Retroactivus Childhoodiness (as opposed to Famishus Famishus).

For yet another installment of G.B. Miller, semi-professional writer, check out my latest @ I Are Writer! 

Until next week, please keep in mind that even though we're about to go through four years of hell on earth with whoever the new occupant of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue will be, worry more about the lethal headache taking place in your own backyard that your friendly neighbor politician will soon torture you with. Because it's the up close and personal that will beat you down, not the yokels in D.C.

(c) 2016 BOOKS BY G.B. MILLER. All Rights Reserved.

12 comments:

  1. I think the only time covers really work is when the new version is completely different from the original, then they can work well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh absolutely.

      A good example is The Hooters cover of "Boys Of Summer". The original had a very fast tempo and they slowed theirs down and extended the song by roughly a minute and a half. Believe me, the song works extremely well with a slow tempo.

      Delete
  2. What's funny is when a band does a new cover of one of their own songs. And does it better. Or sadly, worse.
    Not a fan of Michael Jackson, but Alien Ant Farm did a wicked cool cover of Smooth Criminal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Love that particular version. Never heard of a band doing a cover of their own song. That sounds very scary.

      Delete
  3. I'm not a huge fan of covers either, unless, like Joe said, they truly make it their own. I've heard so many covers where they play the exact same music, with the exact same instruments, in the same tempo, and pretty much just sing karaoke over the original. What's the point of that?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Those kind of cover suck. My main beef with certain covers is if they change to a temp that simple doesn't work.

      Example would be The Ataris doing "Boys Of Summer". They put a ridiculously hard rock tempo to it and slightly tweaked the lyrics by changing Grateful Dead to Black Flag to make it palatable to the hard rock masses.

      Delete
  4. Amen G.B. Well said..." Because it's the up close and personal that will beat you down, not the yokels in D.C." I shall quote you often.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thankee.

      It really is true. D.C. follies only trickle down to the state less than 5% of the time. My stress is what is being inflicted on me in the backyard.

      Delete
  5. I only like cover songs when they really rock them out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Makes sense. I apply the same logic as well, no matter what genre.

      Delete
  6. I heard bluegrass versions of Beatles music from friends in my youth that got me thinking way differently about what music can do to mood....
    Hey I loved "The Mighty Quinn" tune n played the 45 ad nauseum as a teen.

    Almost every original musician I know who has a cd published has a cover tune on there. I don't know why the industry expects that-

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. About the only time I'm pleasantly surprised about cover songs is when I hear one in bluegrass. Beyond that, the bulk of covers out there really annoy me.

      Here's a strange factoid for ya: the last cover listed, which was done by The Ataris, I picked up their c.d. from the library for the grand total of $1. I'm in the process of listening to it right now.

      Delete

These days, the written word is to die for, so please leave a comment that shows me and everyone else the real you. All kinds of verbiage will be cheerfully accepted in the spirit it was written.